Capacity and consent stations in PLAB 2: a simple framework
You may well face a station in PLAB 2 that asks you to assess a patient’s capacity to make a specific decision—usually about treatment refusal. The examiner wants to hear you verbalise the four elements of capacity in plain English, not recite the Mental Capacity Act. Start by stating the decision clearly: “I need to check whether you understand what we’re asking you to decide today.” Then walk through each element as a conversation, not a checklist. If the patient fails any element, say so out loud and explain what you’ll do next (e.g., involve a relative or seek a second opinion). The station is testing your interpersonal skills as much as your clinical judgement, so keep the tone collaborative, not interrogative.
The four elements are: understanding the decision, retaining the information, weighing it up, and communicating the choice. You don’t need to ask them in order, but you must cover all four. If the patient refuses treatment, don’t argue—explore their reasoning to assess whether they’re truly weighing the risks. For example, if a patient with a diabetic foot ulcer refuses amputation, ask, “What do you think will happen if we don’t operate?” Their answer will tell you whether they’re balancing the risks or fixating on one fear. If they can’t retain the information (e.g., they forget the risks you just explained), say, “I notice you’re having trouble remembering what I’ve told you. That makes me think you might not have the capacity to decide today.” Then document it and move to the next step—usually involving a family member or an independent advocate.
Understanding the decision
Start by stating the decision in one sentence: “The decision today is whether to have the operation that removes the infected part of your foot.” Then check understanding: “Can you tell me in your own words what the operation involves?” If they parrot back your words, probe further: “What do you think the surgeon will actually do?” A patient who says, “They’ll cut my foot off” has grasped the core, even if their phrasing is blunt. If they say, “They’ll make me better,” they haven’t understood—they’ve just repeated the outcome, not the intervention. In that case, re-explain and check again.
Retaining the information
After explaining the risks and benefits, ask the patient to recall them: “Can you tell me the main risks of the operation?” You don’t need a perfect recital—just evidence they’ve held onto the key points. If they can’t remember any risks after 30 seconds, say, “I’m going to write them down for you,” and reassess. If they still can’t retain the information, it’s a clear sign they lack capacity for this decision. Don’t rush this step—give them time to process, especially if they’re anxious or in pain.
Weighing it up
This is where you explore their reasoning. Ask open questions: “What’s making you say no to the operation?” or “How are you balancing the risks and benefits?” Listen for evidence they’re considering both sides. A patient who says, “I don’t want to lose my foot, but I know the infection could kill me” is weighing it up. One who says, “I just don’t want it, and that’s final” isn’t—unless they can explain why. If their reasoning is based on a delusion (e.g., “The hospital is poisoning people”), say, “I can see why you’d feel that way, but I don’t think that’s happening here. Let’s talk about what’s actually going on.”
Communicating the choice
This is the simplest element. Ask, “What have you decided?” If they can state their choice clearly—even if it’s a refusal—this element is met. If they’re mute, confused, or change their mind every 30 seconds, they can’t communicate their decision. In that case, say, “I’m not sure you’re able to tell me what you want right now. I’ll need to involve someone who knows you better.”
Worked example: refusal of treatment
Scenario: A 68-year-old man with a diabetic foot ulcer refuses amputation. He’s alert but tearful. Here’s how to structure the conversation:
State the decision: “Mr. Smith, the decision today is whether to have the operation that removes the infected part of your foot. Do you understand that’s what we’re talking about?”
Check understanding: “Can you tell me in your own words what the operation involves?”
- Patient: “They’ll cut my foot off.”
- You: “That’s right. And what do you think will happen if we don’t operate?”
- Patient: “I don’t know. Maybe it’ll get better on its own.”
Explain risks and benefits: “If we don’t operate, the infection could spread to your leg or even your blood. That could make you very ill or even kill you. The operation carries risks too—like bleeding or infection—but it’s the only way to stop the infection spreading.”
Check retention: “Can you tell me the main risks of not having the operation?”
- Patient: “It could kill me.”
Explore reasoning: “You’ve heard the risks. What’s making you say no to the operation?”
- Patient: “I don’t want to be a burden on my family. If I lose my foot, I won’t be able to work or look after my wife.”
Assess weighing: “It sounds like you’re worried about your family. But if the infection spreads, you might not be able to look after them at all. How are you balancing that?”
- Patient: “I know, but I just can’t face it.”
Check communication: “What have you decided?”
- Patient: “I don’t want the operation.”
Conclude: “I can see you understand the risks and you’ve thought about them carefully. You’ve made your decision clear. I’ll respect that, but I’d like to involve your wife in the conversation if that’s okay with you. She might have questions or concerns we haven’t covered.”
If the patient had said, “I don’t want the operation because the nurses are trying to kill me,” you’d explore that further. If it’s a delusion, you’d say, “I don’t think that’s happening, but I can see why you’d be scared. Let’s talk about how we can keep you safe.” Then document the lack of capacity and involve a relative or advocate.
Common pitfalls
Arguing with the patient. If they refuse, don’t say, “But you’ll die!” Instead, say, “I’m worried about what might happen if we don’t operate. Can we talk about that?”
Skipping elements. If you don’t check retention, the examiner can’t mark you for it. Even if the patient seems lucid, cover all four elements.
Using jargon. Say “operation” or “surgery,” not “debridement” or “amputation.” The patient won’t know what those words mean, and it’ll cloud the assessment.
Ignoring cultural or emotional factors. A patient might refuse treatment because of religious beliefs or fear of disability. Explore these, but don’t assume they’re insurmountable. Ask, “Is there anything that would make you change your mind?”
Professional duties in capacity assessments
If a patient lacks capacity, your duty is to act in their best interests. This might mean involving a relative, seeking a second opinion, or—if the decision is urgent—proceeding with treatment without consent. You must also consider whether the patient’s lack of capacity is temporary (e.g., due to pain or anxiety) or permanent (e.g., due to dementia). If it’s temporary, delay the decision if possible. If it’s permanent, document your assessment and involve an independent advocate if the patient has no family.
Confidentiality still applies, but you can share information with relatives or carers if it’s in the patient’s best interests. For example, if a patient with dementia refuses treatment, you can tell their daughter what’s happening so she can help make the decision. However, if the patient has capacity and refuses to involve their family, you must respect that—unless there’s a public-interest disclosure (e.g., risk of harm to others).
Practising for the station
OSCEPilot has mock stations that let you practise capacity assessments with actor feedback. The key is to treat it like a real conversation, not an exam. If you’re rehearsing with a colleague, ask them to play the patient as realistically as possible—tearful, confused, or stubborn. The more you practise verbalising the four elements, the more natural it’ll feel in the exam.
FAQ
What if the patient changes their mind during the station? Reassess capacity. Say, “You’ve changed your mind a few times. Can you tell me what’s making you unsure?” If they’re vacillating because they don’t understand the risks, re-explain and check again. If they’re just anxious, acknowledge it: “It’s a big decision. Let’s take a moment to think about it.”
Do I need to document the capacity assessment in the station? Yes, but keep it brief. Say, “I’ll document that we discussed the risks and benefits, and that you understood and retained the information. I’ll also note that you’ve decided to refuse treatment.” The examiner wants to hear you verbalise the documentation, not write a novel.
What if the patient has capacity but makes an unwise decision? Respect it. Capacity isn’t about making the “right” choice—it’s about understanding and weighing the information. If a patient with a broken leg refuses a cast because they “don’t like the look of it,” you can say, “I understand, but I’m worried about the risks. Can we talk about why you don’t want the cast?” If they still refuse, document it and offer alternatives (e.g., a removable splint).
Can I involve a relative if the patient has capacity? Only if the patient agrees. If they refuse, you must respect their confidentiality. If they lack capacity, you can involve relatives or carers to help make the decision.